Homeowners insurance rates are surging across the U.S., driven by climate change, increased building material costs, and skyrocketing home prices. Nearly half of all property insurance policyholders in the country reported premium hikes over the past year, marking the highest rate of increases in over a decade, according to a recent study from J.D. Power.
Sharp Increases in Homeowners Insurance Premiums
Average homeowners insurance premiums have risen by nearly 70% over the past five years, based on data from ICE Mortgage Technology. On average, single-family homeowners with a mortgage now pay approximately $2,370 per year for their property policy. The most significant price increases in 2025 have been observed in California, where premiums in Los Angeles jumped 19.5% compared to the previous year.
These rising rates are placing significant pressure on homeowners across the country, leading many to reconsider their policies or switch insurers in search of more affordable options. However, experts strongly advise against going without coverage, as the risks of financial devastation can be substantial.
The Rising Cost of Insurance and Its Implications
According to Craig Martin, Managing Director at J.D. Power, the primary issue with rising premiums is the growing dissatisfaction among customers. “All things being equal, if you raise prices, customers aren’t happy,” Martin said. As insurance premiums climb, consumers are beginning to question whether their insurers prioritize customer needs or their own profits.
Insurance premiums are highly dependent on geography, with areas more vulnerable to disasters like hurricanes and wildfires seeing some of the highest rates. Experts link the frequency and intensity of these disasters to climate change, making areas with higher risk levels more expensive to insure.
“The price of insurance is increasing as the level of risk increases,” said Sean Kevelighan, CEO of the Insurance Information Institute. As the risks continue to rise, more Americans are making difficult decisions about their insurance policies.
Forgoing Insurance: A Risky Trend
A significant concern is that rising premiums are prompting more homeowners to contemplate forgoing their coverage altogether. A recent survey by Realtor.com revealed that nearly 60% of respondents might consider not purchasing property coverage if the cost continues to escalate. Hannah Jones, an economic data analyst at Realtor.com, noted, “Households are feeling squeezed, and more are considering going without home insurance altogether.”
Going without homeowners insurance, while financially tempting in the short term, can expose homeowners to devastating risks. In the event of a natural disaster, fire, or other catastrophic event, the costs of repairs or rebuilding can be insurmountable without coverage.
A Growing Trend of Hard Decisions
As insurance premiums continue to climb, Americans are being forced to make tougher decisions about their coverage. For many, rising premiums and higher risk exposure are leading to a reevaluation of the value of their insurance policies. While some may seek alternatives, such as switching to cheaper providers, others may be tempted to take the risky step of going uninsured.
However, experts warn that foregoing insurance is a dangerous choice that could have dire financial consequences in the long run. As climate change intensifies the frequency and severity of natural disasters, having comprehensive coverage remains crucial for homeowners to protect their property and investments.
The increasing cost of homeowners insurance is a trend that is likely to persist in the coming years. With climate change driving higher risks and rebuilding costs, and the rising cost of living adding financial strain, homeowners must carefully weigh the financial implications of their insurance decisions. Finding a balance between affordability and adequate coverage will be a critical challenge for many Americans as the insurance market continues to evolve.
For homeowners, it’s essential to shop around for competitive rates, explore options for reducing premiums (such as increasing deductibles or investing in disaster-resistant features), and carefully assess the risks of going without coverage in an increasingly volatile world.
Related topics:
